Saving the First Amendment from Itself: Relief from the Sherman Act Against the Rabbinic Cartels

By Barak D. Richman

Social Science Research Network, April 12, 2011

America's rabbis currently structure their employment market with rules that flagrantly violate the Sherman Act. The consequences of these rules, in addition to the predictable economic outcomes of inflated wages for rabbis and restricted consumer freedoms for the congregations that employ them, meaningfully hinder Jewish communities from seeking their preferred spiritual leader. Although the First Amendment cannot combat against this privately-orchestrated (yet paradigmatic) restriction on religious expression, the Sherman Act can. Ironically, however, the rabbinic organizations implementing the restrictive policies claim that the First Amendment immunizes them from Sherman Act scrutiny, thereby claiming the First Amendment empowers them to do what the First Amendment was arguably designed to prevent. This essay evaluates this interesting intersection between the Sherman Act and the First Amendment, and it argues that the Sherman Act can, and must, be vigorously applied against the private rabbinic cartels.

Topic: Recruitment and Retention, Congregations and Synagogues, Masorti Judaism, Rabbis, Professional Associations, Conservative Judaism, Law, Economy, Clergy, Synagogues and Congregations

Name of Publication: Working Paper Series

Page Number(s): 1-38

Preview: Download

It appears you do not have a PDF plugin installed for this browser. To be able to preview the PDF, please install a PDF reader such as Adobe Reader.

Genre: Scholarly Journal

Coverage: United States

Language: English

Copyright Holder: Author

Copyright Information: Download for personal use, freely distribute link

Bibliographic Information:
Richman, Barak D. Saving the First Amendment from Itself: Relief from the Sherman Act Against the Rabbinic Cartels. Working Paper Series. Social Science Research Network. 12 April 2011: 1-38.


» View Publication
(PDF, 248 Kb)

Bookmark and Share